The release is anchored in a set of internal findings that AI Digital says demonstrate a stark contrast in outcomes. Advertisers that employ predictive analytics across open platforms are achieving 2.9× higher performance than those confined to proprietary stacks. Teams that can adjust campaigns in real time see a 26% lift in ROI, while organizations that run agile, data‑centric operations are making decisions 73% faster than peers operating within closed environments.
These numbers are not presented as speculative. AI Digital cites its own research, which compares campaign metrics across a sample of open‑ecosystem and walled‑garden buyers. The company argues that the disparity is structural rather than incidental, rooted in the commercial incentives that drive platform owners who control both the supply‑side and demand‑side of programmatic transactions.
Why the “walled garden” matters
A walled garden in ad tech refers to a platform that monopolizes the entire buying and selling process—think of a major social network that both hosts inventory and offers its own demand‑side solution. According to programmatic landscape, this vertical integration creates a “hidden tax” that pushes advertiser costs roughly 20% above the true auction price. The tax is “invisible to most buyers,” the consultancy notes, because the platform’s pricing algorithms obscure the real market value of the inventory.
The impact, programmatic buying says, ripples through the supply chain: inventory pools shrink, attribution becomes fragmented, and third‑party intermediaries prioritize their own margins over the advertiser’s key performance indicators (KPIs). The problem is compounded by the fact that 59% of consumers regularly hop between platforms, a behavior that single‑stack solutions struggle to accommodate efficiently.
The Open Garden Framework: A KPI‑first operating model
The animated explainer is built around the Open Garden Framework, which AI Digital describes as a “KPI‑first operating philosophy.” Rather than offering a proprietary demand‑side platform (DSP) or a closed‑loop solution, the framework is positioned as a neutral set of principles that guide every decision—from supply path selection to audience targeting and measurement—toward the advertiser’s business objectives.
In practice, the framework encourages advertisers to:
- Map supply paths based on cost efficiency and audience relevance, rather than defaulting to a single platform’s inventory.
- Align audience strategies with measurable business outcomes, ensuring that data collection and activation serve a clear KPI.
- Implement real‑time optimization that reacts to performance signals across multiple exchanges, not just the one that owns the data.
- Standardize measurement across open and closed sources, reducing the “black‑box” effect that often plagues walled‑garden reporting.
Stephen Magli, AI Digital’s CEO and Founder, summed up the proposition in a statement released alongside the video:
“With our Open Garden Framework, we’re giving brands and agencies back the choice and competitive advantage they deserve. When your media strategy is engineered around your KPIs instead of a platform’s commercial incentives, the performance gap becomes undeniable. That’s not just a feature—it’s the future of media buying.”
Industry context: The shifting sands of programmatic buying
The timing of AI Digital’s announcement coincides with a broader industry conversation about the sustainability of walled‑garden dominance. Over the past two years, regulators in the EU and the United States have intensified scrutiny of data‑centric platforms, prompting advertisers to seek more transparent, multi‑source solutions. At the same time, the rise of privacy‑first identifiers and the deprecation of third‑party cookies have accelerated interest in “clean rooms” and other collaborative data‑sharing mechanisms that sit outside proprietary ecosystems.
Analysts at Forrester have warned that reliance on a single platform can inflate cost structures and limit reach, especially as younger audiences migrate to emerging social apps that lack robust ad‑tech infrastructure. Meanwhile, a recent eMarketer report highlighted that open‑exchange spend is projected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 12% through 2028, suggesting that the market is already moving toward the kind of multi‑platform approach AI Digital advocates.
The animated explainer: More than a marketing asset
While many agencies release videos to promote new products, AI Digital’s animation serves a dual purpose. First, it distills a complex, data‑heavy framework into a digestible format that can be shared with non‑technical stakeholders. Second, the video is positioned as an editorial asset; the company notes that the visual explainer “is available for embedding and editorial use.”
The animation runs just under two minutes, using a combination of motion graphics and on‑screen statistics to illustrate the performance gap. It walks viewers through a hypothetical campaign that starts in a closed ecosystem, encounters cost inflation and limited attribution, then pivots to an open‑garden approach, unlocking higher ROI and faster decision cycles.
Potential impact on media agencies and brands
If the performance gains cited by AI Digital hold up under independent scrutiny, the implications for media agencies could be significant. Agencies that have built their service models around a handful of dominant platforms may need to re‑evaluate talent allocations, technology stacks, and client reporting structures.
A shift toward open‑ecosystem buying would also demand more robust data‑management capabilities. Agencies would need to integrate multiple data sources, reconcile disparate measurement standards, and maintain real‑time optimization across a broader set of exchanges. This, in turn, could spur demand for new SaaS tools that automate the “supply‑path optimization” and “KPI alignment” steps outlined in the Open Garden Framework.
For brands, the promise of a 2.9× performance lift and 73% faster decision making translates directly into efficient spend. In an environment where media spend is under increasing pressure to deliver measurable results, a framework that demonstrably reduces cost leakage could become a competitive differentiator.
Skepticism and the need for independent verification
Despite the compelling numbers, industry observers caution against taking a single consultancy’s internal research at face value. Independent audits, third‑party benchmarks, and case studies across diverse verticals are essential to validate the claimed lifts.
“Any claim of a near‑tripling of performance should be examined in context,” says Maya Patel, senior analyst at IDC. “We need to see how the methodology accounts for variables like creative quality, audience saturation, and seasonal effects. The walled‑garden bias is real, but quantifying it precisely requires transparent data sharing, which is often hard to achieve.”
AI Digital’s forthcoming all‑in‑one marketing intelligence platform, which the company says will operationalize the Open Garden Framework at scale, could provide the necessary data infrastructure for such verification—provided the platform itself remains neutral and does not re‑introduce proprietary lock‑ins.
Looking ahead: A possible inflection point
The release of the animated explainer may be a signal that the ad‑tech community is reaching an inflection point. As privacy regulations tighten and audience fragmentation intensifies, the economics of a single‑stack, closed‑door approach become less attractive.
If AI Digital’s framework gains traction, it could accelerate a broader industry move toward “open‑garden” strategies that prioritize transparency, KPI alignment, and cross‑platform agility. For advertisers, the promise is clear: higher performance, more efficient spend, and the ability to pivot quickly in a fast‑changing media landscape.
Only time—and rigorous, independent testing—will determine whether the Open Garden Framework can deliver on its ambitious claims, but the conversation it has sparked is already reshaping how the ad‑tech ecosystem thinks about openness, competition, and value.
Get in touch with our Adtech experts
