Artificial intelligence is becoming increasingly common in digital advertising, but consumer confidence may not be keeping pace with its adoption. A new U.S. consumer survey commissioned by Auros, formerly UserTesting, and conducted by Talker Research found that 43% of Americans have felt duped by an AI-generated advertisement, highlighting growing concerns about the accuracy and authenticity of AI-assisted product marketing.
The survey of 2,000 U.S. adults also found that 44% frequently encounter products advertised using some form of AI. More than half of respondents said they do not trust products promoted with AI to match their advertised descriptions.
The findings point to a challenge for advertisers, retailers, and commerce platforms: generative AI can help produce advertising creative at scale, but misleading product representations and unclear disclosures could undermine consumer trust.
For the advertising technology industry, the issue extends beyond creative automation. It raises questions about how brands maintain product accuracy, communicate AI involvement, and protect advertising credibility as synthetic imagery becomes more widespread.
Consumer Confusion Creates New Risks for AI Advertising
One of the survey’s most notable findings concerns consumers’ ability to distinguish authentic product imagery from AI-generated or AI-enhanced visuals.
When shown real products, only 52% of participants correctly identified them. Meanwhile, 31% believed the images were AI-generated, while another 18% classified them as AI-enhanced.
This confusion could affect how consumers evaluate product quality and brand credibility. According to the study, 36% of respondents believe a product is lower quality when AI is used in its marketing, compared with just 17% who associate AI-assisted marketing with higher quality.
These findings suggest that AI-generated advertising can create a perception problem even when the underlying product is genuine.
For retailers, particularly those operating in e-commerce, product imagery plays an important role in purchase decisions. Visual representations help shoppers evaluate appearance, design, materials, and expected product quality. If AI-generated creative changes these characteristics or creates unrealistic expectations, the gap between advertising and the delivered product could increase customer dissatisfaction.
AI Shopping Tools Receive a More Positive Response
The survey also reveals an important distinction between consumer attitudes toward AI advertising and AI-assisted shopping.
Although respondents expressed skepticism about AI being used to sell products, 53% said AI had been helpful while shopping.
The findings indicate that consumers may be more comfortable using AI when it assists their own decisions rather than when brands use it to influence purchasing behavior.
Holiday shopping could accelerate this trend. According to the survey, 54% of respondents plan to use AI for some part of their holiday shopping, while 37% believe the technology will make finding gifts easier.
For retailers and commerce platforms, this creates an opportunity to use AI for product discovery, recommendations, and shopping assistance while maintaining transparency around advertising claims and product representations.
Market Landscape: Generative AI Tests Advertising Credibility
Generative AI is changing how advertisers and agencies develop campaign assets, personalize creative, and produce product imagery across digital channels. Retail media, social advertising, and e-commerce platforms are among the environments where AI-assisted creative can help brands increase production speed and scale content variations.
However, the Auros survey highlights a potential weakness in this model: creative efficiency does not necessarily translate into consumer confidence.
For advertising technology providers, the findings reinforce the importance of creative quality assurance, product-image authenticity, and transparent communication. Advertisers may need stronger review processes to ensure AI-generated visuals accurately represent products, particularly in categories where appearance and product specifications influence purchasing decisions.
The results also highlight a distinction between AI as an advertising production tool and AI as a consumer-facing shopping assistant. While consumers appear receptive to assistance with product discovery, they remain more skeptical when AI influences the way products are presented to them.
Strategic Outlook: Trust Will Shape AI Advertising Adoption
The findings suggest that the next stage of AI adoption in advertising will depend on more than automation and creative scalability.
Advertisers will need to balance AI-driven production with accurate product representation, human oversight, and clear disclosures where appropriate. Agencies and creative technology providers will also face growing pressure to demonstrate that automated creative workflows preserve brand credibility rather than simply increase output.
For retailers, the opportunity is to combine AI-powered recommendations and shopping assistance with trustworthy product information and realistic imagery.
The survey does not establish that AI advertising directly causes lower purchasing intent or reduced conversion rates. However, its findings identify a consumer perception challenge that advertising platforms and brands cannot ignore.
As AI-generated content becomes more difficult to distinguish from authentic product photography, trust and creative authenticity could become important competitive differentiators in digital advertising.
Top Insights
- 43% feel misled: Nearly half of surveyed Americans say they have felt duped by an AI advertisement.
- Consumer skepticism remains high: More than half do not trust AI-advertised products to match their descriptions.
- Authenticity is difficult to identify: Only 52% correctly identified real products in the survey’s image assessment.
- AI shopping assistance gains acceptance: 53% say AI has been helpful while shopping.
- Holiday shopping presents an opportunity: 54% plan to use AI for some part of their holiday shopping.
Get in touch with our Adtech experts.
