Mammoth Brands, the parent company of Harry’s, faces a potential regulatory review after declining to make an unqualified commitment to follow recommendations from the National Advertising Review Board (NARB) concerning advertising claims about its Harry’s Plus razors and competitor Gillette.
NARB, the appellate body of BBB National Programs, found that some claims based on consumer survey data were supported but recommended that Harry’s discontinue several statements it considered unsupported and disparaging toward Gillette. Because Mammoth Brands did not confirm compliance, NARB said it would refer the matter to appropriate regulatory authorities, including the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
The dispute began when The Gillette Company challenged Harry’s advertising before the National Advertising Division (NAD). The campaign included claims such as “70% of Gillette users said they would shave with Harry’s Plus” and “80% of Gillette users like the feeling of Harry’s Plus.”
NAD initially concluded that the claims did not reasonably communicate the implied comparative messages alleged by Gillette. It also found that certain challenged pricing language, while somewhat hyperbolic, was adequately supported. Gillette appealed that decision.
NARB Distinguishes Consumer Preference From Product Comparison
On appeal, the NARB panel found that the references to Gillette users did not directly compare shaving performance or consumer preference between the brands. Instead, the advertising conveyed an overall value proposition: Harry’s Plus could be a satisfactory alternative at a lower price.
The panel determined that the “would shave with” claims were supported by the survey evidence submitted. However, it recommended that Harry’s rely on survey data relating to respondents’ “Brands used most often” when making claims about Gillette users.
This distinction matters for advertisers using consumer research in comparative campaigns. A survey showing that consumers would consider or use a competing product does not necessarily establish that they believe it performs better. The wording and context of a claim can shape the comparison consumers take away from an advertisement.
For marketing teams and agencies, the case illustrates why survey methodology, respondent selection and claim wording need to be aligned before comparative advertising goes live.
Pricing Language and Competitor Disparagement Under Scrutiny
The panel took a different position on Harry’s pricing claims. It recommended discontinuing the phrases “stop getting ripped off” and “taking advantage of you” when directed, either explicitly or implicitly, at a specific competitor such as Gillette.
NARB said the record contained no evidence supporting an allegation that Gillette intended to take advantage of its customers.
The panel also reviewed a Harry’s commercial describing a Gillette razor as “a couple of pieces of metal and some plastic.” It concluded that the language diminished the value and performance of Gillette’s product without supporting evidence. NARB recommended discontinuing both the statement and the Gillette Labs commercial itself.
The decision highlights a distinction between making a substantiated value comparison and suggesting that a competitor deliberately misleads or exploits consumers.
FTC Referral Raises the Stakes for Advertisers
Mammoth Brands said it would carefully consider the NAD and NARB decisions when reviewing existing and future advertising but could not provide an unqualified commitment to comply with the panel’s recommendations.
That response triggered the referral. The FTC is among the authorities NARB identified as potential recipients, although the referral itself does not establish that the FTC has opened an investigation or reached a finding against Harry’s.
For advertisers, agencies and brand owners, the case reinforces the importance of maintaining evidence for comparative claims, especially when campaigns characterize competitors’ pricing, products or business practices.
As brands compete through price positioning and consumer preference messaging, the boundary between aggressive advertising and unsupported disparagement remains an important compliance consideration. The Harry’s-Gillette dispute offers a reminder that even claims grounded in survey research can face scrutiny when their wording implies more than the underlying evidence establishes.
Market Landscape
Comparative advertising is widely used to differentiate products through price, performance and consumer preference. Self-regulatory review bodies such as NAD and NARB provide mechanisms for examining advertising claims and recommending corrective action. The case demonstrates how survey evidence and the interpretation of implied messages can influence the outcome of these disputes.
Strategic Outlook
Advertisers should assess comparative claims at both the evidence and messaging levels. Survey findings need to support the precise statement being made, while language targeting a named competitor requires particular care. The potential FTC referral also underscores that refusing self-regulatory recommendations can bring additional regulatory attention.
Top Insights
- NARB found certain Harry’s Plus claims about Gillette users were supported by survey evidence.
- The panel recommended discontinuing unsupported pricing language targeting Gillette.
- NARB found the “metal and plastic” description of Gillette’s razor unsupported and disparaging.
- Mammoth Brands declined to make an unqualified commitment to comply.
- NARB plans to refer the matter to regulatory authorities, including the FTC.
Get in touch with our Adtech experts.
